Xiao Gong said

Newlywed couple quarreling, wife impulses jump from the ledge died. Her husband that she was weeping now, I do not know his wife jumped. Son-in-law did not believe the rhetoric, the son and relatives to court, said the law did not try to pay attention to the obligations between husband and wife. Marriage law experts said, when the couple quarreled responsibility for the care obligations, including a focus on the safety of the other content.

No wife, the husband should bear responsibility for suicide

□ reporter Ting Yuan

Little good case is about the second trial, this event gave little good parents, Xiao Gong, Xiao Gong parents have left difficult to heal wounds. Zhao still can not understand,http://tabilog25n.com, two 23-year-olds, because of the contradictions in life handled properly, the party will be able to get married only two months to die to protest. As her husband Xiao Gong, now do not know this thing will give him life in the future what kind of impact.

Usually when the couple quarrel between each other really duty of care it,piumini moncler vendita on line?

Neighbors contributed to their children became man and wife

Mr. Zhao was his wife totter up the stairs, his legs have a disability, but he insisted on going to the stairs. In their own home where the next layer of the stairs, Mr. Zhao subconsciously stopped to meditate something.

A year ago,piumini moncler vendita on line, he was living daughter to live here. Her son at home with his family just across the floor, and sometimes he came up from downstairs, her daughter would wait for him at the door, affectionately call him Dad. But now, the 23-year-old daughter did not, she is from their own bedroom window in the jump off. Elderly woman mourning, Mr. Zhao think everything is gone.

Daughter and son Jia Xiao Gong has recognized twenty years, but also because they met two live this floor. Zhao Xiao Gong's parents and son are old acquaintances, four elderly people in this unit for over 20 years, neighbors, neighborhood relations along victorious in distant relative.

Seeing a pair of children grow up, Mr. Zhao and his wife Ma Gong couple joked that my daughter and your son is very young, the relationship between our two so well, simply let the two of them make up a pair now. Zhao Gong and then chuckled, not seriously. Who knows, say those proffering small Xiao Gong was really good and the initiation of mutual affection.

Soon, the two children together. Four elderly people was so happy. Two people fell in love a few years, but there has been no talk of marriage, both parents look in the eyes of anxious heart. Zhao Gong couples couple said: Our home is not too small, do not let them out to buy a house, the young couple lived in our house, so little good from her family too near. In this way, the marriage thing implemented houses, small Jia Xiao Gong is urged to register as soon as possible to get married.

July 17, 2008, as "80" after the two young people registered to get married. According to the original plan, little good and Xiao Gong Xiao Gong and she was admitted to the parents' house.

However, married life did not become sweet start. Little good and live with her in-laws, some of the details of life began to feel uncomfortable, Xiao Gong and also due to the small good thing or a contradiction. Xiao Gong do in a hotel manager, his honeymoon just to catch up on the Beijing Olympics, when the hotel's heavy workload, Xiao Gong are working every day to come home late at night, sometimes even staying at the hotel. Little good because her husband collectively overtime and night out, my heart had a grievance.

The couple began to quarrel,http://youkem.com/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=35372, Xiao Gong strange little good do not understand themselves, have little good to complain Xiao Gong did not love her, Xiao Gong even suspected of having an affair. Xiao Gong's parents heard the couple quarrel, but easy to persuade poor, could do nothing but sigh. Xiao Gong mother sometimes do this at night, Xiao Gong child's father to comfort his wife: "How does the couple's nothing serious quarrel,outlet hogan roma, quarrels passed?!"

However, the two old people can not think of any case, "big" really took place.

Husband and his new wife after quarrel "jumping"

September 18, 2008 night, Xiao Gong home. Worried about him little good because there has been no sleep, to see her husband, he complained that he was too late to come back. Xiao Gong work day, tired and unwilling to respond to the complaints of small good. See Xiao Gong little good to ignore their own,http://info-mobilestyle.com, are greatly wronged. So, the little good start to cry, Xiao Gong did persuade them, swearing irritably. Two people thus more noise the more interest. According to Xiao Gong said that the day the two of them from the middle of the night have been quarreling violently before dawn. Finally, two people lying on the bed crying,http://www.thiefmissions.com/search.cgi, Xiao Gong facing the wall crying, crying back to him little good.

I do not know what time, terrible scene took place - little good to stand up from the bed, to the window, jump and jumped down ......

After the incident, the small good parents trying to restore the true process that scene, they find the police to help find a neighbor asked, also questioned the little good in-laws. However, only a small room, good and Xiao Gong, what happened at that moment,woolrich outlet firenze, only Xiao Gong clear.

Xiao Gong said, in an instant small good jumping, he was still crying, did not notice the small windows good jump. He found little good to cry for a while behind no cries, then back to observe the movement, only to find no small good figure. Then he suddenly saw an open window, and immediately realized that might hurt. By this time, little good has fallen from a high level to fall to the ground Qijueshenwang,moncler junior, left this world.

Aware of the accident, Xiao Gong immediately notify parents lived in the next room, and also notify the parents of the little good.

Police rushed to the scene, after investigation, ruled out the possibility of homicide. Little good parents can not accept the reality of the death of her daughter has been that night they talked of her daughter, after a few hours how to jump from the window of? Who pushed her daughter this step? Zhao couple lived with these questions.

Zhao repeated questioning son: Before little good jump, you arguing about? Little good to say there is no death for you to see that kind of thing?

Xiao Gong said he did not remember the little good said so, just ask him little good,scarpe hogan donna, is not it already do not care about myself.

Zhao did not know then how much credibility son, they were only young couple in the room, her daughter has gone,tn requin homme, now dead no check against.

"I know her room, the windows are high, between the bed and the window when a big empty, stood a table. People want to jump, do not step on the table can not reach the window sill. A large living stepped up the window table, so big moves, son do not know that? "Zhao said on unsuspecting son strong dissatisfaction.

Little good mother also endorsed her husband's judgment. She added: "My daughter is a little fat, she can not very smooth local jump from the window, she was so fat, you want to jump certainly a great movement, not only does not know how the son-in-law, and even lived in the same suite yard? The laws should also be able to hear the movement. "Mr. Zhao couple grew more and more confused,outlet hogan sito ufficiale,http://www.minimax-ei.com/sitio/index.php?option=com_community&view=profile&userid=80691, in addition to liability law does not say that little good to hear the couple's parents so bitter quarrel without even asking why, if the in-laws heard movement in the past comfort, and maybe her daughter would not have committed suicide.

Elderly couple sued the son angrily

Little good suicide completely changed the lives of two people. Better than a distant relative of the previous four elderly people, strangers now, not even meet. Mr. Zhao and Ms. Ma Xiao Gong and deliberately avoided with his parents, to see them, the couple will think Mr. Zhao daughter. Mr. Zhao couple in mind, Xiao Gong son's death on the small good inescapable responsibility, Mr. Zhao Xiao Gong hope can compensate themselves economically. Zhao demanded compensation of $ 200,000, but Xiao Gong refused.

After the Spring Festival in 2009, Mr. Zhao couple angrily, filed a lawsuit to the Beijing Chaoyang District Court. In the complaint,moncler torino outlet, Mr. Zhao wrote: After the two sides quarrel, his daughter got up from the bed and climb the ledge, window, falls in the process, the son should have foreseen the consequences of his wife's behavior may arise, but failed to fulfill the obligation to protect the rescue , despite the consequences of the death of his wife occurred, should be held accountable.

In addition, with their daughter's in-laws live next door,http://www.k-macs.ne.jp/~anb/cgi-bin/nicky.cgi,scarpe uomo hogan, only separated by a wall, a bitter quarrel on the couple informed but not stop, so the results of her daughter's death should bear some responsibility. The son of a violation of the right to life of her daughter, to the plaintiff caused great mental harm, should bear tort liability. Son claims to 150,000 yuan compensation for death, mental damages of $ 50,000.

Chaoyang District Court accepted this case, and the first trial in April. Court, Mr. Zhao and Xiao Gong couple, Xiao Gong parents appear in court, the original old neighbors, friends, relatives, and now sitting opposite sides. "When the hearing, both sides are relatively stable mood, no quarrel, and no blame each other, but some of the facts and the man's responsibility to have a different understanding." The plaintiff's attorney couple Zhao told reporters.

The focus of dispute between the parties is whether there is some suggestive language before action or small good at jumping, Xiao Gong was little good to know whether to jump,requin tn pas cher, he is blocking good little dangerous actions. For part of the responsibility, Xiao Gong believes that his wife little good for suicide have a moral obligation, but there is no legal obligation. But lawyers believe Bo Xiangxi, Xiao Gong as a small good husband to his wife are obliged to note that this is a matter of principle obligations under the Marriage Act.

Specific to the prevailing situation, Xiao Gong should be able to note that little good jumping dangerous actions, of course, also an obligation to stop her. Xiao Gong has a duty of care, but in the subjective ignore this obligation, and therefore responsible for the suicide of his little good. As Xiao Gong's parents, they usually never had a quarrel to the intensity, it should be able to foresee the consequences of serious quarrel, but they do not act in a negative way neglect this duty of care.

While the legal responsibility to understand their own, but Xiao Gong and his parents think that they should be given some compensation Zhao couple. So the judge presided over both sides in court mediation, but the amount of compensation, the two sides at loggerheads over. Bo Xiangxi lawyer said Zhao couple compensation 150,000 yuan, Xiao Gong said he does not have this capability. Xiao Gong court mediation pay 10 million, but Xiao Gong and his parents say they do not have so much money. Due to the amount of compensation the parties can not agree, the day of the mediation failed.

After the trial, Mr. Zhao leg on crutches with a disability under his wife's arm,http://www.radio4.ru/cgi-bin/search.cgi, slowly out of the courtroom. See this desolate scene, BU lawyer said he was sad: "Xiao Gong also feel the pain, but also feel sorry for the old man, but he says he has no money .10 ten thousand yuan is not a small number, but Xiao Gong's income, the The money is in 2023 can earn more. The money and the girls parents will suffer, hurt compared to what it really is not. "

Have a duty of care between husband and wife?

Husband did not kill his wife, who committed suicide in front of her husband, the husband of his wife's death is responsible?

The first hearing, the trial judge asked the plaintiffs attorney Bo Xiangxi, he proposed what is the legal basis for compensation reason? Bo Xiangxi said at the time, noting that there are mutual obligations between husband and wife. Please indicate Judge legal provenance of this obligation. Bo Xiangxi thought answer, duty of care between husband and wife is given to the principle of the Marriage Law.

However, this still does not make the case to answer the defendant convinced. Really have a duty of care between the husband and wife do? Either commit suicide if things too hard, because the other party would ignore the duty of care and assume responsibility? Inevitably couples quarrel, if one death threats, we should always pay attention to the other party the other party, if not seriously, the other to find a really short-sighted, the other party must responsibly it?

According to this logic, the couple quarrel this norm, suddenly became heavy. In an interview with reporters, the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences Research Center of the Prospect Gender and Law, the researchers said, does little good case should go to married duty of care issue.

The Prospect, said: "Xiao Gong's death does little good for the responsibility, but the responsibility is not because of their marital status generated, but because they are fierce fight this behavior of the two heated argument, if not a couple, but also due. quarrel behavior increased attention to each other, the obligation of concern. In addition to commit suicide in this extreme case, arguing the party sudden illness are also likely to occur, then the other party has an obligation to hospital in a timely manner. If the other party found but ignored, That he would bear responsibility for the consequences. The key issue in this case is that Xiao Gong was good and in the same small room, he should be able to perceive the small good jumping action, can be perceived but did not stop, in which case it is the premise of his responsibility. "

Peking University professor Ma Yinan marriage law when analyzing small good case, said: "Similar cases have occurred in our country, as a husband, Xiao Gong liability is inevitable because of the Marriage Law provides for the obligation of mutual respect between husband and wife faithful support. Usually we only pay attention to a couple of mutual support obligation of economic dependency, ignoring the spiritual comfort, in fact, contains the spirit of dependency content of the obligation to take care of. When the husband and wife quarrel, both sides bear the same moral obligation to take care of, there is of course also includes the concerned about the safety of other content, it does not need to be specifically described the law. This is like firemen have the obligation to put out the fire, of course, also have the obligation to save people from the scene of the same. "

However, this does not mean the death threat as long as the spouse, the person must bear the corresponding risks. Professor Ma Yinan, said: "The law does not encourage couples to the threat of death, and can benefit the most critical plot case is the presence of her husband watching his wife committed suicide and did not stop,http://www.amy.hi-ho.ne.jp/cgi-bin/user/masuda/pcbbs_sub.cgi?mode=howto, the husband often responsible for some death threats. other couples,hogan outlet torino, if the other party that the other party just 'scare' own, no more to pay attention to and prevention of suicidal behavior results of the other really implemented, then the judge will be at the discretion of the sentencing process. such cases, judges need specific case analysis Discretion. "Even if the legal relationship could clarify, small good young lives are irreparable.